---
title: "Unequal Family Patrimony Division: Economic Injustice ✦ Goldwater Droit"
meta:
  "og:description": "Learn when Quebec courts may grant an unequal partition of the family patrimony. Only economic injustice qualifies — not adultery, betrayal, or misconduct."
  "og:title": "Unequal Family Patrimony Division: Economic Injustice"
  description: "Learn when Quebec courts may grant an unequal partition of the family patrimony. Only economic injustice qualifies — not adultery, betrayal, or misconduct."
---

![1443249338 1200x563](https://goldwaterdroit.com/_vercel/image?url=%2F_content-assets%2Fblog%2F2022%2F06%2Funequal-partition-of-family-patrimony-a-question-of-economic-injustice%2Fimages%2F1443249338_1200x563.jpg&w=1536&q=80)

[News & Insights](https://goldwaterdroit.com/en/news-insights)

# Unequal partition of family patrimony: a question of economic injustice

14 June 2022

3 min read

[Family Law](https://goldwaterdroit.com/en/news-insights?topic=family-law) [Asset & Property Division](https://goldwaterdroit.com/en/news-insights?topic=asset-property-division) [Articles & Analysis](https://goldwaterdroit.com/en/news-insights?category=articles-analysis)

## Quebec's Family Patrimony

Introduced in 1989 by the Bourassa government, the family patrimony is a legislative particularity of Quebec which aims to create a third patrimony in which the spouses invest financially in the name of an entity called "The Family". Concretely, the Quebec legislator wanted to protect the interests of the married spouses by imposing on them the financial pooling of what was invested within the family during the union. To do this, the family residences, the property adorning them, the pension plans and funds that have been contributed to during the union, accumulated annuities, and vehicles used for family travel all make up this patrimony which is partitioned at the dissolution of marriage.

## What Qualifies for Unequal Partition?

For some spouses, it may be tempting to think that the Courts will would grant a request for unequal partition of the family patrimony if their ex-spouses acted abusively or unfairly during the marriage. However, it is imperative to understand that the unequal partition of the family patrimony does not seek to remedy any "moral" injustices committed during the marriage.

Indeed, many are those who might think to ask for unequal division of the family patrimony following adultery, betrayal, or spousal violence. However, the injustice justifying an unequal division within the meaning of [article 422 of the Civil Code of Québec](https://www.legisquebec.gouv.qc.ca/en/version/cs/CCQ-1991?code=se:422&history=20231025) is solely economic. The [Supreme Court of Canada in M.T. v. J.‑Y.T. of 2008](https://decisions.scc-csc.ca/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/4104/index.do) crystallized the interpretation of this provision as follows:

> The interpretive approach to be taken in applying art. 422 must always be consistent with the objective of the family patrimony, that is, to create an economic union between the spouses. Such an approach will enable the court to determine what circumstances might result in an injustice within the meaning of art. 422. Those circumstances must be related to the success or failure of the economic partnership between the parties. It must be determined whether, by their actions or conduct during the marriage, the spouses defaulted on their fundamental obligation to contribute to forming and maintaining the family patrimony: […]

### Valid Grounds for Unequal Division

Although the squandering of property, acts of bad faith, or the short duration of the marriage is a non-exhaustive list of the reasons justifying an unequal distribution of the family patrimony, any claim in this sense must necessarily have its source in the economic nature of the family.

Thus, no adultery or deception can be compensated by an unequal division of the family patrimony. On the contrary, it will be necessary to turn to civil or criminal proceedings to obtain compensation for those damage suffered.

## Navigating Quebec's Family Patrimony Laws With Expert Guidance

The family patrimony system in Quebec creates unique challenges when a marriage or civil union is dissolved.

Goldwater Droit is a [Montreal law firm](https://goldwaterdroit.com/en) specializing in family law and estate law. Our [family law lawyers](https://goldwaterdroit.com/en/services/family-law-lawyer) provide specialized expertise in navigating complex patrimony divisions.

WRITTEN BY:

#### Sandrine Dagenais

_Associate at Goldwater, Dubé from 2022-2024_

[**Previous Post**Frequently asked questions about child support](https://goldwaterdroit.com/en/news-insights/2022/06/frequently-asked-questions-about-child-support) [**Next Post **Longueuil Deer: Court of Appeal to Hear Me Goldwater, SPCA & Sauvetage Animal Rescue](https://goldwaterdroit.com/en/news-insights/2022/10/longueuil-deer-court-of-appeal-to-hear-me-goldwater-spca-sauvetage-animal-rescue)